Legislators grew frustrated with New York State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT) Commissioner Joan McDonald at a hearing last week, bristling at what Senator Diane Savino (D-Staten Island/Brooklyn) called her “almost deliberate opaqueness” during a session about the department’s proposed 2012-13 budget.
Governor Cuomo’s budget makes significant infrastructure investments, and the public is eager for details about its spending targets and financing. When legislators inquired, though, Commissioner McDonald was short on information.
Senator Fuschillo (R-Merrick) asked for a list of bridges and roads that would be repaired with the $4.5 billion allocated to the NY Works plan.
“We’re working on the list,” replied McDonald.
Fuschillo also asked for more information on the plan to consolidate NYSDOT’s regional offices.
“We’re studying that now,” said McDonald.
Senator Golden (R-Brooklyn) asked about funding the Tappan Zee Bridge replacement.
“We’re looking at all the options,” McDonald said.
In a moment of frustration, Senator Golden rhetorically asked, “how are we supposed to make an informed decision when your responses are uniformly ‘we’re studying that’?” (The Senate and Assembly evaluate the Governor’s budget every year).
Information-hungry legislators emphasized the need for a Memorandum of Understanding between the agency and the Legislature on the NYSDOT Capital Program’s targets. They also reminded McDonald that the Western New York NYSDOT region was shorted $167 million in 2008 and asked for a regional breakdown of NYSDOT’s spending.
Commissioner McDonald had a firmer answer for Senator Liz Krueger (D-New York), who asked if any of the projects in the NY Works plan were for public transportation, as opposed to just roads and bridges. McDonald answered in the negative, but said that that NYSDOT was “working with the federal government to assist upstate [transit] systems.”
This is just bizarre. We’re in NY, with the most amount of mass transit per capita in the nation. And the entire NY Works plan is for roads?
[…] confirmed that transit won’t be included in the fund at a legislative hearing two weeks ago. According to the Tri-State Transportation Campaign, Manhattan State Senator Liz Krueger asked McDonald whether any transit projects would be eligible […]
[…] confirmed that transit won’t be included in the fund at a legislative hearing two weeks ago. According to the Tri-State Transportation Campaign, Manhattan State Senator Liz Krueger asked McDonald whether any transit projects would be eligible […]
[…] The issue is particularly pressing because a vital part of Governor Cuomo’s financial roadmap remains unclear. According to the executive’s proposed budget, the NY Works Fund has $5 billion that will go to building a new Tappan Zee Bridge, but there have been no further details on how the project or NY Works will be funded. During January, when Senator Charles Fuschillo (R-Merrick) asked about the program to no avail, legislators commented about the challenges of analyzing such an opaque budget. […]
[…] And by “no one,” of course, we mean: the public, the advocates, the legislators, the transportation staff. In other words, everyone outside of the “four men-in-a-room”, and perhaps their respective staff members. Back in January, both were promised to be imminently forthcoming. And this isn’t the first time lists like these haven’t been forthcoming. […]