Archives
Categories

Cuomo Promised Transparency, But NYS Agencies Have Been Largely Opaque

FOIL-extension-2
“Due to the complexity of the request, and the volume of records which need to be identified and retrieved, it has taken longer than anticipated to respond.”

While transparent State government was a key point in Governor Cuomo’s “Clean Up Albany” manifesto, one tool that was supposed to be crucial for transparency, the Freedom of Information Law (FOIL), has instead yielded less information lately.

Access to data from New York State has been an ongoing challenge. Nearly all of the FOIL requests Tri-State has made have been met with delays, most often in the form of (multiple) deadline extensions. Much of the information requested has been from the New York State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT), including information on the Tappan Zee Bridge financing plan and environmental impact state/bus rapid transit cost estimates and the cancelled Strategic Transportation Enhancements Program (STEP). But these types of denial-through-delay tactics are not NYSDOT specific. In fact, a recent watchdog report by Gannett found that “Administration agencies have a pattern of multiple deadline extensions on [FOIL] requests. The extensions are routinely blamed — without specifics — on the large number of FOIL requests the state receives.”

The delay in production of the STEP records requested by Tri-State is an unfortunate — yet typical — example of how the delays happen. NYSDOT, through a STEP announcement, requested funding applications for high-priority transportation projects in each of NYSDOT’s 11 regions. The program, however, was abruptly cancelled, despite the fact that applications had already been submitted. To better understand transportation needs throughout the state, Tri-State sought to examine the applications and submitted a FOIL request in February 2013 for the applications, yet to date, NYSDOT has not produced the requested materials. The Department’s most recent request for extension came in November, making a total of five of extensions in a ten month period.

This lack of transparency extends beyond FOIL requests. This past summer, NYSDOT was criticized for leaving the community in the dark as plans to revamp a 16-mile stretch of Sunrise Highway in Nassau County were coming together. The lack of outreach prompted a coalition of elected officials, business groups and advocates (including Tri-State) to send a letter to Commissioner Joan McDonald requesting a meeting to discuss the plans.

In addition, the State plans to continue the opacity surrounding the use of dedicated transit funds for non-transit purposes. In 2011 and again earlier this year, Governor Cuomo did not sign bills — unanimously passed by the legislature — that would have ensured funds dedicated to transit would only go toward transit costs. The resistance to these “lockbox” measures continues to leave open the possibility that transit funds could easily (and without explanation) be siphoned away by the administration to close up funding gaps elsewhere in the budget.

A lack of transparency has been noted by others, too. In a recent piece by Liz Benjamin, she notes:

Cuomo’s attempt to position himself as “absolutely transparent in everything he does,” in the words of Lieutenant Governor Bob Duffy, turned to mush in fairly short order. While he improved access to some online data, the data were provided selectively. And the administration’s overall relationship with the media has been extraordinarily bad.

While technological tools championed by Governor Cuomo have made more information available in general, the poor response rate to FOIL requests is a red flag that the State wields powerful discretion over what specific information the public can actually gain access to.

Share This Post on Social
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Chop Hardenbergh
Chop Hardenbergh
10 years ago

While sad, NYSDOT is only displaying the same disregard for the public as the White House, MassDOT, and NHDOT, to name other agencies. Has anyone seen a sociological study of how these agencies get so hunkered down and fearful of the very public they are supposed to serve?

I truly do not understand the internal powers which are striving to push the door closed (if not lock it!) before that precious information escapes.

I am thankful to Maine DOT and Maine DEP, here where I live, as well as Vermont AOT, which are much more open.

Chop

Chalmers (Chop) Hardenbergh, editor
Atlantic Northeast Rails & Ports
weekly trade newsletter covering
New York, New England, Maritimes, & eastern Quebec.
vox/cell 207-865-2922, fax 866-484-4490
editor@atlanticnortheast.com
http://www.atlanticnortheast.com
PO Box 357, Freeport, Maine 04032

trackback

[…] Governor Cuomo has received criticism for his lack of transparency, at least there is a law that protects the public’s right to attain information. This simply […]

2
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x